How to grow a profitable mailing list with MailerLite

How to grow profitable email marketing list

Money is in the list” is something you must’ve heard if you’re in any kind of online business. For months, I’ve seen and received many different questions on why one should start a mailing list, how to do that, and, after all, what to do with it?! Therefore, this post has arrived. E-mail marketing for bloggers: why & how to grow a profitable mailing list.


Let me warn you right here: this guide might get a bit long. It will consist of 3 parts:

  1. Why should start an email list?
  2. How to get new subscribers? + MailerLite tutorial 
  3. How to make your list profitable? All about email marketing funnels + how to do evergreen launch campaign

Let’s get started, shall we?

This post includes affiliate links. 


How to grow a profitable mailing list with MailerLite


E-mail marketing for bloggers: why & how to grow a profitable mailing list

PART #1: Why you should start an email list?

Here are some of the main reasons why having an email list is crucial for any online business owner:

  • The list is YOURS and no one can take it away from you
  • The list will consist of people INTERESTED in your offering
  • You’ll have the one-step access to your audience
  • It’s money! 2-3% of the list converts

Let me explain a bit more!

REASON #1: The list is YOURS and no one can take it away from you

In the online world, things are changing rapidly. Just because we’ve been on Facebook for years and it has become a part of our lives, doesn’t mean that it will be around forever. Just because you’re successful and well-known on one platform, you never know what can happen and when it can be shut down for all kinds of reasons.

The same goes for possible online fraud, closing of your account or anything alike. At the end of the day, your email list might be your only personal trace to your online followers you have left!

Relying on social media following has another downfall – there are all kinds of rules controlling your interaction with your followers.

Let’s say you have 2K followers on Facebook. How many of them will actually see your post? Exactly. Up to 10%, if you’re lucky and super smart about it. Unless you invest some money in ads. The same pattern follows any other social media platform.

Therefore, it’s important to learn how to make a profitable mailing list.

Having an email list gives you the option to set your own rules – when, how often and how you want to reach out to your subscribers. And it’s a valuable option to have!


REASON #2: The list will consist of people INTERESTED in your offering

If someone has signed up for your list, the first barrier is won and they are already interested in your offer. Whether it was your provided opt-in or your enchanting teaser of all the info you’ll be sending, you’ve already won their email address and it’s A LOT.

It’s not a secret that people hate getting spam and we usually just don’t have time to read through all of the emails that come into our mailboxes. Giving permission for you to actually send them an email is a huge deal! You’re now personally invited to their private space to share what you have to say. Make sure to use this option right!


REASON #3: You’ll have the one-step access to your audience

As I already mentioned before, social media and other platforms you might be using to reach out to your subscribers are somewhat restrictive in many different ways.

Not all of your followers will be on Twitter at the moment of your tweet, not all of them will be chosen to see your Facebook page content. Also, not always you might be able to share and publish whatever you want. For example, if you’re an active member of Facebook groups, they have many restrictive NO PROMO rules. The same goes for Pinterest group boards… So you always have to be somewhat sneaky to actually share your message.

Which is a totally different story for your mailing list! Having a mailing list actually gives you ONE step access to your audience with WHATEVER you have to provide! Are you interested in more blog readers? Send them your latest blog post. Would you like to share your new e-book? Send them the link. Are you interested in sharing more about you? Add a video to your email. So many different options that’ll get RIGHT INTO THEIR MAILBOXES.

And yes, still not everyone will see or open your email. Having a 100% open rate is a fairytale. But open and conversion rates will be way bigger than on any other platform!


REASON #4: It’s money! 2-3% of the list converts

These are kind of imaginary numbers but I’ve heard them a lot from many different campaigns. For most people, the list conversion rate will be at least 2-3%. From there, it’s just numbers game.

If you have 100 subscribers, you can sell to 2-3 people. If you’ve been mindful of your list building process and provided relevant information, your conversion rates can be even bigger. Imagine, what happens when you have 1000 or 10000 subscribers. It’s money! You have one-step access to money, literally.

The numbers will be different based on your email marketing strategy but if you follow the steps I’ve listed in the following PART #3 you definitely can grow your conversion rates!

Do you feel a bit more confident about the idea to build your list? Here’s something very important to note: don’t build a mailing list just because I or someone else said you so. Building an email list without the right intention and mindset will be a waste of your time. All I can say – having a mailing list works!


How to get more email list subscribers


PART #2: How to get new subscribers?

I believe this is the number one question from “how to grow a profitable mailing list” question list. To make sales, get the money rolling in and build a fan base from your email subscribers, you actually need some signups. So let’s take a moment to understand HOW to get new subscribers.

I’ve used 4 different email marketing platforms and you can choose yours over here. This time, I’ll give you the preview of making the signup form on MailerLite. MailerLite is an email marketing software that gives you the option to use the service for free for up to 1000 subscribers. They also have landing pages and great WordPress plugin to use.

STEP #1: Create an opt-in

First, you have to create a free opt-in specific to your perfect audience. The person who’ll be interested in what you have to share.

To create the perfect opt-in you have to consider several things but first of all – how can you ADD VALUE to your perfect audience? What skills and knowledge you can use to help THEM with their needs? Keeping in mind that it should stay relevant to your field of expertise! For example, food bloggers are offering free recipes, graphic designers – design templates, marketers – e-books, craft makers – how-to videos. Just to get your ideas rolling!

Opt-in creation really can be considered as the biggest time-investment in your funnel creation. Usually, it’s great to have several opt-ins all over your website, attached to relevant blog posts.

For example, I have two main opt-ins: Blog Creation Simplified and Bulletproof Pinterest Strategy eBooks.

A few ideas to keep in mind when creating your opt-in:

  • Make it simple and easy to use
  • Use various opt-ins for different posts
  • Promote your opt-ins where relevant
  • Don’t overthink it. Create, update, change. Just start making things happen!

Once you have created a free opt-in, you have to build a funnel. In simple words, a funnel is the email sequence people will go through until your offering. And keep this in mind – mailing list can be used for ANY of your online offerings. Whether you’re selling services, courses or want to promote your affiliate links.

As I already mentioned, you can choose any of the email marketing software but for this sample, I have chosen MailerLite: it’s for free up to 1000 subscribers, it’s easy to use and great for starters. You can sign up over here.

STEP #2 (On MailerLite): Create Subscriber group

Let’s say, you’re adding an opt-in for your whole website and it will be “Guide to write the best blog post ever“. The first step is to create a Subscriber group where all of your subscribers will be sent to. We can call the group “Bloggers“.

To do that, choose Subscribers > Groups > Create a new group, as shown below.

STEP #3 (On MailerLite): Create a signup form

Once you have created a group where all of your email subscribers will be gathered, it’s time to create an actual form through which people will get your free opt-in!

Before starting, here’s a quick review of the available signup forms:

  • Popup. You can create various kinds of popup – the one that’ll appear on the bottom or top of the page, slider popup which will appear in the corner, full-page popup or just the regular kind.
  • Landing pages. Well, the name says it all. You can create a landing page and add it to the subdomain of your website like I’ve done with
  • Embedded forms. These are the basic forms you can add to your blog posts or over the website.

It’s possible to customize all of the forms!

So, first of all, you should choose which form to use. I suggest starting with a simple embedded form and, later on, experiment with others.

Click Forms >> Embedded forms >> Create embedded form

After choosing which Subscriber form it will go to (Bloggers), the design part comes in!

Keep the design branded and aligned with your website. Simplicity is the key! Here’s one of my form designs. It’s not showing up fully since the width of the form is set to be wider than the editing field is but it’s working on the website! (Always check!!)

STEP #4 (On MailerLite): Create double opt-in with your freebie

On top of the form, you have the option to set up double opt-in. This option will be the best way to send your subscribers their freebie so check YES!

Once you allow the double opt-in to be active, you’ll have to create Confirmation email & Confirmation Thank you page. In the confirmation emails button, you can add the download of the file you’re providing or the link to it. So the acceptance of joining your list leads to the download of the freebie.

STEP #5: Add Form on your website

For WordPress users:

  1. Get MailerLite plugin
  2. Create a new form in the plugin and base it on existing MailerLite form
  3. Call it as necessary for you to remember what form is related to
  4. Go to a blog post, use MailerLite plugin icon and add form. Voila!

Popup forms will be seen on the website right after you turn them on.

For other website users: you should add form code to the blog post. You’ll find it in Embedded form info.

STEP #6: Create an automated email sequence

More on that – in the next part when we’ll talk more about how to make your mailing list profitable!


PART #3: How to make your list profitable?

Marketing king ClickFunnels have created a Bootcamp all about making your list and growing your income. Join the 100-day challenge here. 


I hope you’ve got some additional information & inspiration on how to grow a profitable mailing list!


  • Jane
    December 7, 2017 at 12:15 pm

    I am still struggling with this, My subscriber’s number is stuck in the same place. Thank you for sharing this. I need to learn more about MailerLite 🙂 sounds like a good option for me.

    • Ieva Laicane
      December 8, 2017 at 1:12 pm

      MailerLite definitely saved my mailing list with so many easy to customize options. You can always just give it a try since it’s for free. Best of luck! 🙂

  • Perri
    December 7, 2017 at 1:00 pm

    This is really useful info! I have been thinking about whether I should start a mailing list for my blog and wondering how I will go about it. Thank you for sharing your advice!

    • Ieva Laicane
      December 8, 2017 at 1:11 pm

      Amazing! I’m excited that you found this post useful. The secret really is to just get started. You can figure out the rest afterward 🙂 Cheers!

  • Bethany
    December 7, 2017 at 1:22 pm

    Some great tips here, I’m going to figure out how to do some of them now!

    • Ieva Laicane
      December 8, 2017 at 1:03 pm

      Yay! I’m happy to hear you’ve found this useful. Best of luck in your creative endeavors! 🙂

  • Ashli
    December 7, 2017 at 2:49 pm

    I LOVED this post! I use MailChimp and it doesn’t come close to what you can do on Mailer Lite, is it free? I have my own online business and have been wracking my brain to try and figure out the best way to interact with them and how to segment them, so this tell helps. What opt in platform do you use? I also have my own blog I started just a couple of months ago and I just don’t like my opt in service, it’s through Mail Chimp. What do you use? I love the layout of your blog as well! Very nice!

    • Ieva Laicane
      December 8, 2017 at 1:02 pm

      Yes, MailerLite is free for up to 1000 subscribers. Afterward, it’s way more budget-friendly than any other email marketing platform. I use MailerLite for opt-ins as well – it provides all the forms I might need so it’s easy to get people to sign up. Let me know if you have any more questions about this, I’ll be happy to chat more 🙂

  • Nicole
    December 7, 2017 at 4:47 pm

    I’m a huge fan of Mailerlite and Convertkit! Therefore I’m super glad that you recommended Mailerlite! Great article.

    • Ieva Laicane
      December 8, 2017 at 12:59 pm

      Oh, I absolutely love them both as well 🙂 Thanks for your feedback!

  • Tisha
    December 7, 2017 at 6:29 pm

    This is a great post! I recently signed up to get my own mailing list because I wasn’t happy with the service WordPress was providing but I hadn’t thought about the monetary aspects, it was just a decision made in haste. This has definitely made me think more. Thanks for sharing!

    • Ieva Laicane
      December 8, 2017 at 12:59 pm

      As long as you’ve started your mailing list – there’s no need to rush into the monetary aspect of it. You can monetize it whenever your business needs it! Just don’t forget to provide some useful info for your list meanwhile so they get familiar with you. Cheers!

  • Alysia
    December 8, 2017 at 8:12 am

    A lot of this is super daunting until it’s broken down easily like you’ve done here. Glad I came across your blog today- I’m hanging out for a while 😛

    • Ieva Laicane
      December 8, 2017 at 12:57 pm

      Yay! I’m excited to hear you’ve found this useful 🙂 Let me know if you get any questions along the way or you have any other specific topics you’d be interested in. Cheers!


Leave a Reply

five + eleven =

Ready to create a course? Join Kickstart Your Course Creation CHALLENGE 2022!